Mutual fund vs index fund: What’s the difference?

If you go with an actively financial plan meaning managed mutual fund, you could spend more time researching which fund to invest in. There can be a wide range of different strategies, fees, and long-term performance from fund to fund. You also may want to pay closer attention to the investments in the fund, as the manager could change their approach over time.

Key differences between actively managed mutual funds and index funds

• There are no guarantees that working with an adviser will yield positive returns.
• Mutual fund managers aim to outperform the market benchmark, which translates to higher fees and risk than index funds.
• Any estimates based on past performance do not a guarantee future performance, and prior to making any investment you should discuss your specific investment needs or seek advice from a qualified professional.
• It’s possible a particular actively managed mutual fund may no longer be appropriate for your goals at some point.
• Most mutual funds are actively managed, which means they have a team of professionals working behind the scenes picking and choosing the stocks, bonds or other investment options to include inside the fund.

Choosing between index funds and active mutual funds hinges on individual investment objectives. Index funds tend to have lower fees and tax efficiency and typically mirror market benchmarks, suitable for those prioritizing broad market exposure at minimal costs. Conversely, active mutual funds seek to outperform the market and offer the potential for higher returns but may incur higher fees and could underperform their benchmarks. The decision revolves around whether investors prioritize consistent returns and cost-effectiveness (index funds) or seek potential outperformance and active management strategies (active mutual funds). Actively managed mutual funds involve fund managers who aim to outperform the market through strategic investment decisions.

The opinions expressed on our site are solely those of our expert finance editors and analysts, and they are not influenced by advertisers or external sponsors. Cashtopedia is independently owned and operated, and our dedicated team adheres to strict publishing standards to ensure our content remains unbiased and reliable. Please note that while we strive to cover a broad range of financial offers, not every market offer is featured here.

Index Funds Vs. Mutual Funds: Understanding The Key Differences

We can better understand index and mutual funds by discussing the differences in goals, management style, costs, diversification and risk. Index fund refers to the investment objective of a fund, whereas mutual fund or ETF describes the vehicle, which has an impact on when you can trade shares and how it’s taxed. Index funds tend to be more tax-efficient than mutual funds because they don’t trade securities as frequently. On the other hand, mutual funds often experience higher turnover, which can result in more taxable events. It’s important to note that the higher the investment fees are, the more they dip into your returns. If you purchase shares of an actively managed fund expecting to yield above-average returns, you may be disappointed, especially if the fund underperforms.

Tax Efficiency:

For example, the expense ratio of an index fund may be as low as 0.05%, whereas mutual funds typically charge around 0.46% on average. Index funds, whether mutual funds or ETFs, track a market index to match its performance. Both can be good options for those avoiding DIY investing, but it’s crucial to understand each fund’s workings, objectives, and fees. Remember that the fees of an index fund or mutual fund can dip into your returns. Some mutual funds are index funds, but it’s also common for investors to invest in both index funds and active mutual funds in their portfolios for further diversification and possibly get higher returns.

Why choose Index Funds over Mutual Funds?

Whether it’s focusing on a specific industry, supporting only environmentally friendly companies, or prioritizing growth over income, there are index funds and active mutual funds for many different goals. Both allow for diversification of your investments, potentially reducing the risk of investing too heavily in any one asset. If you’re aiming for market-average returns and prefer a more hands-off investment, index funds are the better choice. However, if you believe in the potential of active management and want the chance of outperforming the market, mutual funds may be right for you. In comparison, active mutual funds involve a fund manager trying to beat an index, such as by regularly selling and purchasing shares to try to maximize the returns of its investment portfolio. Index funds and actively managed mutual funds both allow you, with a single purchase, to immediately have exposure to many investments.

Investment Goals

However, index funds have fees as well, though the lower cost of running such a security usually results in lower fees. Remember, the lower the management fees, the more the shareholder can receive in a return. Large-cap MFs are more stable, while mid- and small-cap MFs may offer higher growth potential but with increased volatility. Actively managed MFs aim to outperform benchmarks, especially in rising markets. However, achieving this consistently is challenging, and performance may vary. Again, passive investing beats active investing most of the time and more so over time.

It’s possible a particular actively managed mutual fund may no longer be appropriate for your goals at some point. Index funds and mutual funds are both great investment options, but they each have their own advantages and disadvantages. If you’re looking for a low-cost, low-risk way to invest in the stock market, then index funds are a good choice.

The ultimate goal is to mirror the overall index’s performance and deliver similar returns to the fund’s investors. And the good news is you don’t have to do all this research on your own. You can work with a financial advisor or investment professional to help you identify and choose which funds to include in your Roth IRA and 401(k). Choosing the right fund depends on your investment goals and risk tolerance. Index funds have lower fees, reduced risk, and eliminate human bias, making them a reliable choice for passive investors. After you factor in all the fees, the better-performing mutual fund still outperforms the index fund by about $26,000—and that’s assuming you don’t add a single penny!

• Unlike a mutual fund, an ETF has a value that fluctuates on a public exchange throughout a trading session.
• An equity mutual fund generally has the highest allocation toward stocks, but there can be some differences among various funds.
• If you’re willing to take on more risk in the hopes of earning higher returns, then mutual funds may be a better option.
• One of the most significant differences between index funds vs mutual funds is how they are managed.
• If you go with an actively managed mutual fund, you could spend more time researching which fund to invest in.
• Therefore, there is no need to buy and sell securities regularly.

You can also consider diversifying your portfolio by investing some amount of money in Index and other Mutual Fund types. An equity mutual fund generally has the highest allocation toward stocks, but there can be some differences among various funds. While many equity funds only hold stocks, some might hold some cash or a small slice of other assets like government bonds. Here’s what you need to know when choosing between index and active mutual funds.

However, with an actively managed mutual fund, the performance is based on the investment decisions the fund managers make. Fund managers are free to choose the securities that best meet the investment objective and character of the fund. When exploring investment options, you would have come across the terms ‘index fund’ and ‘mutual funds’. While they may seem different, it is important to understand that there is no such thing as ‘index fund vs mutual fund’. Mutual funds, in general, are categorised into two main types – actively managed funds and passively managed funds. Over the long term, index funds tend to perform better than actively managed mutual funds.

While this opens the door for higher potential gains than index funds, it also means returns might lag the index. The broad stock market might be up while an active mutual fund is down, for example, although the opposite can also occur. Because there are many different types of mutual funds, it’s hard to generalize the pros and cons. Here, however, we’ll compare the pros and cons of active mutual funds. Mutual funds are trying to pick a mix of stocks that will beat the average returns of the stock market or a particular benchmark index. The investing information provided on this page is for educational purposes only.

Have a bank FD in your name? Get a credit card against it

An index fund is a type of mutual fund or exchange-traded fund (ETF) designed to mirror the performance of a specific financial market index, such as the S&P 500 or the Dow Jones Industrial Average. It operates by holding a diversified portfolio of securities weighted to represent the index it tracks, aiming to replicate its returns. These funds offer broad market exposure at a relatively low cost as they passively follow the index rather than actively trading securities. Whether an index fund is better than an active mutual fund depends on various factors, including individual investment goals, risk tolerance and preferences. Due to their passive nature, they often perform in line with market benchmarks, making them suitable for investors seeking broad market exposure at lower costs.

Investors who seek higher-than-average returns may be more drawn to mutual funds. However, since there is more work required to actively manage a mutual fund, it may cost more. There is a constant debate on which is better, actively or passively managed funds. According to the SP Indices, 78% of large-cap funds underperformed the S&P 500 within five years. This highlights that even though the market has experienced high volatility in the last few years, active funds don’t necessarily yield better-performing funds. While mutual funds are the better choice for your retirement investments, that’s not to say index funds never have a place in your investing strategy.

Views expressed are as of the date indicated, based on the information available at that time, and may change based on market or other conditions. Unless otherwise noted, the opinions provided are those of the speaker or author and not necessarily those of Fidelity Investments or its affiliates. Fidelity does not assume any duty to update any of the information. A manager that performed well in the past is by no means guaranteed to do well in the future. In fact, even high-performing managers often have lagging periods.